Real estate negotiations rarely end with the first offer. Whether you’re a buyer or seller, understanding how to handle a counteroffer can help you get the best deal while keeping negotiations on track. A well-structured counteroffer can help you negotiate a better purchase price, adjust contingencies, or align closing timelines to meet your needs.

What Is a Counteroffer in Real Estate?

A counteroffer is a response to an initial offer made in a real estate transaction. When a buyer submits an offer, the seller has three choices:

Seller’s Options	Description
Accept	Approve the offer as-is and proceed with the sale.
Reject	Decline the offer with no further negotiation.
Counteroffer	Propose new terms, such as price adjustments, changes to contingencies, or modified closing dates.

If the seller counters, the buyer can accept, reject, or submit another counteroffer. This process continues until both parties agree or negotiations break down.

How Sellers Use Counteroffers

Sellers often issue counteroffers to improve the terms of a deal. Common reasons include:

Seller’s Goal	Counteroffer Strategy
Increase purchase price	Request a higher price if the buyer’s offer is below expectations.
Modify contingencies	Remove or adjust contingencies to make the deal more favorable.
Adjust closing date	Align closing dates with the seller’s moving schedule.
Change earnest money terms	Increase the deposit to secure a stronger buyer commitment.

Example: If a seller lists a home for $220,000 and receives an offer for $200,000, they could counter at $210,000 rather than rejecting the offer outright. This keeps negotiations open while moving closer to their desired price.

To strengthen a counteroffer, sellers often include comparative market analysis (CMA) data to justify pricing and set an expiration date to encourage a quick response.

How Buyers Use Counteroffers

Buyers can also submit counteroffers to negotiate better terms. Common reasons include:

• Negotiating a lower price if the home is overpriced or needs repairs.
• Requesting seller concessions to cover closing costs.
• Adjusting the closing date for personal or financial reasons.
• Asking for repairs based on a home inspection report.

Example: If a seller counters at $210,000 but an inspection reveals $10,000 in necessary repairs, the buyer may counter at $200,000 to account for the added costs.

Buyers can submit multiple counteroffers until both parties reach an agreement or one party withdraws.

What Happens If a Counteroffer Is Rejected?

If a counteroffer is rejected, you typically have two options:

Once a counteroffer is made, the previous offer is no longer valid. If the other party rejects it, you can’t accept the original offer unless they resubmit it.

Working with a real estate agent can help you craft stronger counteroffers that align with market conditions and the other party’s motivations.

When Should You Accept a Counteroffer?

Deciding whether to accept a counteroffer depends on several factors:

Consideration	Why It Matters
Market Conditions	In a competitive market, a reasonable counteroffer should be accepted quickly.
Budget Limits	Ensure the final price aligns with your financial situation.
Contract Contingencies	Review financing, inspections, and other conditions.
Timeline	If you need to move quickly, accepting a fair offer prevents delays.

A counteroffer is not legally binding until both parties sign the agreement. If negotiations drag on, sellers may receive more competitive offers from other buyers.

Key Strategies for Crafting a Strong Counteroffer

Whether you’re buying or selling, these tactics can help you negotiate effectively:

• Respond quickly – A fast response keeps momentum and prevents other buyers or sellers from stepping in.
• Set an expiration date – Creating urgency (typically 24-48 hours) prevents delays.
• Know your limits – Sellers should determine their lowest acceptable price, and buyers should set a maximum offer before countering.
• Consider more than just price – Adjusting contingencies, covering closing costs, or modifying timelines can be just as valuable.
• Stay professional and flexible – Keep emotions out of negotiations and focus on securing a fair deal.
• Be willing to walk away – If terms don’t meet your needs, exploring other options may be the best decision.

Can Sellers Make Counteroffers to Multiple Buyers?

Real estate laws vary by state regarding multiple counteroffers. Some states require sellers to disclose that multiple offers are in play, while others allow them to negotiate with multiple buyers privately.

If you’re selling a home, consult a real estate agent to ensure compliance with local regulations and avoid legal complications.

When to Walk Away from a Real Estate Negotiation

Sometimes, a deal isn’t worth pursuing. It may be time to walk away if:

Reason	Why It’s a Deal Breaker
Low appraisal	If the home’s appraisal is lower than the agreed price and the seller won’t adjust.
Inspection issues	Major repairs needed, and the seller won’t cover costs.
Financing problems	Buyer or seller financing falls through.
Title complications	Legal issues with property ownership arise.
Prolonged negotiations	If another opportunity becomes available.

Consult your agent if you’re unsure whether to proceed.

Should You Counter a Lowball Offer?

Sellers often receive lowball offers—those significantly below the asking price—and must decide whether to counter or reject them outright.

While some lowball offers come from buyers who aren’t serious, others may be testing negotiation limits. Instead of rejecting them immediately, consider:

• Whether the buyer is open to negotiation – Some buyers start low but are willing to compromise.
• The home’s market value – Reviewing recent comparable sales can help determine a fair price.
• The buyer’s reasoning – If their offer is based on repairs or market conditions, there may be room to negotiate.

If the buyer is serious, countering with a reasonable price can keep negotiations open and lead to a mutually beneficial deal.

How to Make a Winning Counteroffer

Mastering the real estate counteroffer process requires strategy, flexibility, and an understanding of market conditions. Whether you’re a buyer or seller, a well-crafted counteroffer can help you secure the best deal while keeping negotiations on track.

If you’re navigating a real estate transaction, working with an experienced real estate agent can provide valuable guidance and improve your chances of success.

Get My Custom Rate Quote

No SSN required. Zero impact to credit. Your Information is never sold.